E-mail from Antoinette  Baldwin to Miami City Commissioners


From: Antoinette  Baldwin

To:  Commissioner Angel Gonzalez, Commissioner Jeffrey L. Allen, Commissioner Joe M. Sanchez, Commissioner Johnny Winton , Commissioner Tomas P. Regalado

Cc: Mayor Manuel A. Diaz

Sent: Wednesday, April 13, 2005   12:45 PM 

Dear Commissioners,

At the March 24th city commission meeting, Commissioner Allen asked the Home Depot representative the size of their smallest Home Depot. The Home Depot representative said about 100,000, not including the garden center. Would you have removed the maximum size limitation for a store in Coconut Grove and/or voted differently if the Home Depot representative had truthfully answer the question that the smallest store size is around 70,000 square feet? Why is there a need to negotiate with Home Depot if they have already submitted plans for a building permit and are grandfathered in? Wouldn't the size limitation only apply to future big boxes. Also, why does Home Depot have to apply for a Class 11 Permit if they are grandfathered in?

I respectfully ask these questions as a confused concerned resident of this city.

Antoinette Baldwin
Coconut Grove
Miami, Florida 33133 

PS:The picture below looks like the one architect Max Strang showed at the Coconut Grave Village Council meeting as an example of an architecturally friendlier Home Depot store.


Home Depot urban concept in Canada

A mention of lifestyle centres in Canada by the ICSC included a hint: the first completed lifestyle center, the Village at Park Royal in North Vancouver, includes a 70,000 sq ft design-focused Home Depot with a round, street-facing, two-level layout. It looks quite good from these photos from architect MDMA.